I really like my Colibri lighter! It always lights my cigar perfectly. I buy mine off of E-bay - seems I usually save a lot of money and the merchandise is just as good as from a dealer. (As a sidebar, I bought a 50 cigar humidor off of E-bay and it is the best desktop humidor I have ever had!)
Maybe I'm different (wait, I know I'm different! ), but I really have become accustomed to a punch for most of my cigars. I don't know why, but the draw seems to be better with a punch.
Received my Palio cutter this week and I’m kind of disappointed. I found the plastic case to be rather cheap in its appearance and feel. While I admit it cuts well, in my opinion, it’s not really any better than my Xikar. Regardless, it's still another toy to play with.