Cigar Forums banner

Discussions Showcase Albums Media Media Comments Tags Marketplace

1-20 of 51 Results
  1. General Cigar Discussion
    Being new to cigars the things I would pinpoint when rating a cigar would be, Appearance, Draw, Flavor, Burn, Enjoyment, and, Price. When i smoke i like to have somthing to drink during the first half or so to clean my pallet after every draw to get a "propper" tasting of the cigar. (I say...
  2. Tobacco Legislation
    Yesterday, Scientific American posted an online article stating that "An analysis of top-grossing movies from the last decade shows that films with smoking make less money." It also reports that the Center for Tobacco Control Research and Education (CTCRE) at the University of California...
  3. Tech Corner
    I really should know this but how do you leave trader rating without hunting through the forums looking for the person you want to leave feedback for??
  4. Site Help and Suggestions
    I left a bad rating by accident for Jazzmunkey. I don't even know how I pulled it off. I just don't want Kevin waltzing around with a less than perfect rating. If a mod could PLEASE fix I would appreciate it. Thanks!
  5. Cigar News, Videos, Reviews, Interviews, etc
    I picked this up because of the ratings it got in Cigar Aficionado and because of the low price. The cigar is beautifully wrapped with a nice sheen... Read the full review here: Casa Magna Torito Cigar Review - Lives up to the rating
  6. Non-Habanos Reviews
    Oliva Serie O Wrapper: Sun-Grown Habano Binder: Nicaraguan Habano Filler: Nicaraguan Habano Vitolas: 9 Natural Size: 5x43 This was purchased as a single at a local B&M for $6 on friday, spent 3 days in my 67% RH humidor with...
  7. General Cigar Discussion
    LOL... It's been a long time since I logged in and wanted to throw out a belated April Fools :biggrin: How is everyone doing?
  8. General Cigar Discussion
    So I see all these cigars advertised as 90-rated, 92-rated, etc. They are all quality cigars and I am always intrigued to try them based on this "rating." My question is, are the high-end rare cigars ever rated? When I think of a DPG Cuban Classic gettnig a 92 rating and an Oliva Serie V...
  9. General Cigar Discussion
    My Cigar rating system: 5 = I will buy more and rave about them to others. 4 =Memorable, will smoke them again 3= Good tasting, but I don't care If I don't smoke another one. 2= Only if they are free or when I am drunk 1= Why do they even sell them??? I won't smoke them even if they are free
  10. General Cigar Discussion
    True story. Just saw it in the CA Insider myself. All 90+, averaging 91 pts through all sizes.
  11. General Cigar Discussion
    With the CA ratings recently past I've been talking with a lot of people about magazine ratings, online ratings, reviews, etc. All of the systems have pros and cons (well not all of them - some just suck) but I was curious what everyone else thinks. Looking at the factors below, what order...
  12. iPhone Cigar Review Application
    After using the app more (which I love) have a few more feature requests. I'll submit each with a separate subject so it makes it easier if others search the forums or have comments on a feature. In another post I mentioned that I think an avg rating for the cigar (across sizes) would be nice...
  13. General Cigar Discussion
    I've been smoking cigars regularly for about 6 years now and I finally feel my palate has developed enough to rate my own cigars. I am curious as to how CA can rate cigars so highly, yet their description makes the stick sound horrible. Things like "papery, damp finish" and "acidic, tannic, and...
  14. General Cigar Discussion
    I remember hearing about this a while ago. Just food for thought. Start quote: "Smoking in youth-rated movies has not declined despite a pledge two years ago by Hollywood studios to encourage producers to show less "gratuitous smoking," according to an anti-smoking group. The American Medical...
  15. General Cigar Discussion
    another copy from famous Say, what's the deal with those cigar ratings you read in magazines like *Cigar Aficionado*, *Smoke* and others? How do their "judges" determine whether a cigar is a "70" or a "90?" As subjective as rating cigars may be, especially when it comes to taste, they all use...
  16. Non-Habanos Reviews
    I wanted to create this thread for 2 reasons. 1 give a deeper understanding of my rating system and 2. Have a thread I can put a link to in my signature so those who don't know can check it out if they care (which most won't buy there might be a few) I do a simple impression of the cigar what I...
  17. General Cigar Discussion
    What is it?
  18. General Cigar Discussion
    I have smoked cigars for several years and I am starting to save my bands and rate the cigars I smoke. They all seem to be good. Help with some suggestions on how you would rate your Cigars. Thanks
  19. General Cigar Discussion
    Well, I have accepted the fact that I will never have the ability (or maybe the desire) to review cigars like the Klugs, Poker, Silverfox, Pnoon, Chibnkr, Vstromark, Raisins etc etc of the world. I wish I could but I have to face the facts and just admit that I'm not capable of it. Trying to...
  20. General Cigar Discussion
    358 - 89 Points 464 - 87 Points 460 - 86 Points 466 - 85 Points
1-20 of 51 Results